From 19dbc8a160800e2804e9b1b6abb3839fbfc75d7d Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Natalie Weizenbaum <nex342@gmail.com>
Date: Mon, 24 Oct 2016 17:22:49 -0700
Subject: [PATCH] Document the package's internal architecture. (#487)

---
 CONTRIBUTING.md     |   7 ++
 doc/architecture.md | 236 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 2 files changed, 243 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 doc/architecture.md

diff --git a/CONTRIBUTING.md b/CONTRIBUTING.md
index ffe7d49b..7c7ec791 100644
--- a/CONTRIBUTING.md
+++ b/CONTRIBUTING.md
@@ -48,3 +48,10 @@ All files in the project must start with the following header.
 Contributions made by corporations are covered by a different agreement than the
 one above, the
 [Software Grant and Corporate Contributor License Agreement](https://developers.google.com/open-source/cla/corporate).
+
+### Package architecture
+
+For details on the architecture of this package, see
+[this document][architecture].
+
+[architecture]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/doc/architecture.md
diff --git a/doc/architecture.md b/doc/architecture.md
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..d1669ae1
--- /dev/null
+++ b/doc/architecture.md
@@ -0,0 +1,236 @@
+# Test Package Architecture
+
+* [Code Organization](#code-organization)
+  * [Frontend](#frontend)
+  * [Backend](#backend)
+  * [Runner](#runner)
+* [Lifecycle of a Test Run](#lifecycle-of-a-test-run)
+  * [Loading a Suite on the VM](#loading-a-suite-on-the-vm)
+  * [Loading a Suite in the Browser](#loading-a-suite-in-the-browser)
+
+## Code Organization
+
+From a user's perspective, the test package provides two main pieces of
+functionality: an API for defining tests, and a command-line tool to run those
+tests. The structure of the package reflects this division. The code is divided
+into three main sections: the frontend, the backend, and the runner.
+
+### Frontend
+
+The [`lib/src/frontend`][frontend] directory contains APIs that are exposed to
+the user when they import `package:test/test.dart`. This includes core functions
+such as `expect()` and `expectAsync()`, test-specific matchers such as
+`throwsA()` and `prints()`, and annotation classes such as `TestOn` and
+`Timeout`. The functions that define the top-level structure of the test, such
+as `test()` and `group()`, are defined in `lib/test.dart`, but they can be
+thought of as frontend functions as well.
+
+[frontend]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/frontend
+
+The frontend communicates with the backend using zone-scoped getters.
+[`Invoker.current`][Invoker] provides access to the current test case to
+built-in matchers like [`completion()`][completion], for example to control when
+it completes. Structural functions use [`Declarer.current`][Declarer] to
+gradually build up an in-memory representation of a test suite. The runner is in
+charge of setting up these variables, but the frontend never communicates with
+the runner directly.
+
+[Invoker]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/invoker.dart
+[completion]: https://www.dartdocs.org/documentation/test/latest/test/completion.html
+[Declarer]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/declarer.dart
+
+### Backend
+
+The [`lib/src/backend`][backend] directory contains classes that represent the
+in-memory structure of a test suite. A [`Suite`][Suite] represents a single test
+file, and class contains a tree of [`Group`][Group]s, each of which contains
+many [`Test`][Test]s. These classes are built using a [`Declarer`][Declarer].
+
+[backend]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/backend
+[Suite]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/suite.dart
+[Group]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/group.dart
+[Test]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/test.dart
+
+The backend also contains the [`Invoker`][Invoker], which is responsible for
+actually running an individual test case—including tracking how many outstanding
+asynchronous callbacks are pending, handling exceptions, and timing out the test
+if it takes too long. The `Invoker` provides information about the status of a
+running test as streams and futures on a [`LiveTest`][LiveTest] object.
+
+[LiveTest]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/lib/src/backend/live_test.dart
+
+The backend provides a bridge between the frontend and the runner. The runner
+sets up the `Declarer` and starts the `Invoker`, which the frontend functions
+then communicate with directly.
+
+### Runner
+
+The [`lib/src/runner`][runner] directory contains the code that's executed when
+`pub run test` is invoked. It's in charge of locating test files, loading them,
+executing them, and communicating their results to the user. It's also by far
+the biggest section. For more information on the runner architecture, see
+[Lifecycle of a Test Run](#lifecycle-of-a-test-suite) below.
+
+[runner]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner
+
+## Lifecycle of a Test Run
+
+To understand generally how the test runner works, let's look at an example run.
+When the user first invokes `pub run test`, the command-line arguments and
+[configuration files][] are combined into a single
+[`Configuration`][Configuration] object which is passed into the
+[`Runner`][Runner] class. The `Runner` is mostly just glue: it starts up the
+various components necessary for a test run, and connects them to one another.
+It's also in charge of handling certain `Configuration` flags.
+
+[configuration files]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/blob/master/doc/configuration.md
+[Configuration]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/configuration.dart
+[Runner]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner.dart
+
+The first thing the runner starts is the [`Engine`][Engine]. The engine iterates
+through a test suite's tests and invokes them in order. It knows how to handle
+set-up and tear-down functions, and how to combine the output of multiple test
+suites running concurrently. It exposes its progress through a collection of
+getters and streams that provide access to individual [`LiveTest`][LiveTest]s.
+
+[Engine]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/engine.dart
+
+The runner then passes the `Engine` to a [`Reporter`][Reporter], which listens
+to the `Engine`'s streams and exposes the information there to the user, usually
+by printing human-readable text. [`CompactReporter`][CompactReporter] is the
+default on Posix platforms, but others may be selected based on the
+`Configuration`. Nearly everything the user sees comes through the reporter.
+[Reporter]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/reporter.dart
+[CompactReporter]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/reporter/compact.dart
+
+The `Engine` and `Reporter` can't do much of anything, though, without any test
+suites to run. The next step is to load those suites. The [`Loader`][Loader] is
+in charge of this part. It takes in file or directory paths and finds all the
+test files they contain—by default any files matching `*_test.dart`. It then
+proceeds to load each file on all the platforms specified in the `Configuration`
+that's also supported by the test suite.
+
+[Loader]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/loader.dart
+
+The specifics of loading suites differs based on whether the platform is a
+browser or the Dart VM. I'll cover each platform below, but for now let's stick
+to what they have in common. Every platform will emit a
+[`LoadSuite`][LoadSuite], which is a synthetic [`Suite`][Suite] containing a
+single test that, when invoked, produces the actual `Suite` defined in the test
+file.
+
+[LoadSuite]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/load_suite.dart
+
+Wrapping the loading process in a synthetic `Suite` gives us the very useful
+invariant that *all test errors occur within a `Suite`*. Loading can fail in all
+sorts of ways—the code might not compile, the `main()` method might throw, the
+browser might not be installed, and so on. Locating those errors within a
+`Suite` means that the `Engine` and `Reporter`, which already know how to deal
+with test errors, can deal with load errors in exactly the same way. It makes
+the load process a little more complex, but it makes everything else a lot
+cleaner.
+
+Once a `Suite` has been loaded, the runner does a little post-processing to make
+sure the `Configuration` is handled properly. It filters out tests whose tags
+don't match the `--tags` flag, or whose names don't match the `--name` flag.
+Then it passes the resulting `Suite`s on to the `Engine` and they begin to run.
+
+### Loading a Suite on the VM
+
+Let's start with looking at how suites are loaded on the Dart VM, since the
+process is substantially simpler than loading them on a browser. This loading is
+handled by the [`VMPlatform`][VMPlatform], which extends the
+[`PlatformPlugin`][PlatformPlugin] class. [Eventually][issue 49], we plan to
+support a user-accessible platform plugin API, so we model platforms as plugins
+to prepare for that.
+
+[VMPlatform]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/vm/platform.dart
+[PlatformPlugin]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/plugin/platform.dart
+[issue 49]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/issues/49
+
+In its simplest form, a `PlatformPlugin`'s responsibility is just to create a
+[`StreamChannel`][StreamChannel] that connects the test runner to a remote
+isolate—everything else is handled by helper functions. The `VMPlatform` uses
+[`Isolate`][Isolate]s to dynamically load its test suites, and then communicates
+with them using an [`IsolateChannel`][IsolateChannel]. It passes in a `data:`
+URI containing Dart code that imports the user's code, and runs that code in the
+context of the [`serializeSuite()`][remote platform helpers] helper, and the
+`PlatformPlugin` superclass deserializes it on the other side using
+[`deserializeSuite()`][platform helpers].
+
+[StreamChannel]: https://pub.dartlang.org/packages/stream_channel
+[Isolate]: https://api.dartlang.org/stable/latest/dart-isolate/Isolate-class.html
+[IsolateChannel]: https://www.dartdocs.org/documentation/stream_channel/latest/stream_channel/IsolateChannel-class.html
+[remote platform helpers]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/plugin/remote_platform_helpers.dart
+[platform helpers]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/plugin/platform_helpers.dart
+
+When a test suite is serialized and deserialized, it's not just converted to and
+from some static representation like JSON. The [`Engine`][Engine] needs
+fine-grained control over the remote suite, and the [`Reporter`][Reporter] needs
+fine-grained access to the [`LiveTest`][LiveTest]s it emits. To make this work,
+the helper functions use the [`MultiChannel`][MultiChannel] class to tunnel
+streams for each test through the main `IsolateChannel`. Each test has its own
+virtual channel that gets a message when the test runner calls
+[`Test.load()`][Test], and that sends messages back to indicate the progress of
+the test.
+
+Information about these virtual channels, as well as test names and metadata,
+are bundled up into a JSON object and sent over the `IsolateChannel` to be
+deserialized. The deserialization process then converts them into
+[`RunnerTest`][RunnerTest]s within a [`RunnerSuite`][RunnerSuite], which the
+`Engine` can then run just like normal `Test`s in a normal [`Suite`][Suite].
+
+[MultiChannel]: https://www.dartdocs.org/documentation/stream_channel/latest/stream_channel/MultiChannel-class.html
+[RunnerTest]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/runner_test.dart
+[RunnerSuite]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/runner_suite.dart
+
+### Loading a Suite in the Browser
+
+The [`BrowserPlatform`][BrowserPlatform] class also extends
+[`PlatformPlugin`][PlatformPlugin], but rather than just emitting a
+[`StreamChannel`][StreamChannel] and letting the plugin helpers do the rest, it
+takes more control over the loading process. It emits its own
+[`RunnerSuite`][RunnerSuite], which allows it to expose its own
+[`Environment`][Environment] to enable debugging.
+
+[BrowserPlatform]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/browser/platform.dart
+[Environment]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/environment.dart
+
+Whereas the [`VMPlatform`][VMPlatform] loads each separate suite in isolation,
+the `BrowserPlatform` shares a substantial amount of resources between suites.
+All suites load their code from a single HTTP server, which is managed by the
+platform. This server provides access to Dart entrypoint wrappers for Dartium
+and content shell, to compiled JavaScript for other browsers, and to HTML files
+that bootstrap the tests.
+
+In addition to sharing a server, when multiple suites are loaded for the same
+browser, they all share a tab within that browser. Each separate browser is
+controlled by its own [`BrowserManager`][BrowserManager], which uses
+`WebSocket`s to communicate with Dart code running in the main frame—also known
+as [the host][host].
+
+[BrowserManager]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/browser/browser_manager.dart
+[host]: https://github.com/dart-lang/test/tree/master/lib/src/runner/browser/static/host.dart
+
+Each browser is spawned with a tab pointing to
+`packages/test/src/runner/browser/static/index.html`, the host page. The host's
+code then opens a `WebSocket` connection to a dynamically-generated URL. This
+URL tells the `BrowserPlatform` which `BrowserManager` to send the `WebSocket`
+to.
+
+To load a suite for this browser, the `BrowserPlatform` passes the URL for that
+suite's HTML file to the `BrowserManager`, which in turn sends it down to the
+host page. The host opens this HTML in an iframe, opens a
+[`StreamChannel`][StreamChannel] with this iframe using
+[`Window.postMessage()`][Window.postMessage]. It then tunnels this channel
+through the `WebSocket` connection, again using [`MultiChannel`][MultiChannel],
+so that the `BrowserManager` has a direct line to the iframe where the tests are
+defined.
+
+[Window.postMessage]: https://api.dartlang.org/stable/latest/dart-html/Window/postMessage.html
+
+From this point forward the process is similar to `VMPlatform`. The iframe
+serializes its test suite using [`serializeSuite()`][remote platform helpers],
+and the `BrowserManager` deserializes it using
+[`deserializeSuite()`][platform helpers]. It's then forwarded to the `Loader`
+via the `BrowserPlatform`.
-- 
GitLab